5 Comments
User's avatar
Paul_'s avatar

The Hunter/Farmer explanation of ADHD “symptoms” is very interesting and hopeful for many people. It goes towards also explaining things like the animosity between white collar and blue collar, academics and labor and other class problems.

Is there anyone teasing out the Hunter/Farmer aspects from other psychological influences for people currently diagnosed with ADHD? It seems that there are a lot of things lumped into the ADHD diagnosis that might be Hunter versions of things like stress, trauma, etc., which would be better assessed directly than by hit and miss attempts with drugs and social isolation.

Also, what are your thoughts on people who are somewhat both Hunter and Farmer, like me and maybe even yourself? I feel that’s my case and it seems plausible, especially considering that two people who have a baby may themselves represent both Hunter and Farmer.

Gwen Diehn's avatar

I have long been unhappy with the rigidiity of our school systems-- the rows of desks, the lectures, the fill-in-the-blanks worksheets, etc. My happiest time as a student was when my sixth grade teacher sensed my boredom and insttead of treating it as though I had a disability, she asked me to be the class librarian, and she also started a class newspaper with me as the editor. Both these positions involved getting out of my desk and working on my own in a different room and doing something useful and interesting.

I went into teaching with the intention of changing it and loosening up things so that kids liike me as well as what we now call Farmers could choose the environment that worked best for them. And I never used the perjurative terms 'deficit' or ' disorder.' Happily, in this country during the 60s and 70s we had a brief period when the British Plowden Report opened at least some alternative schools on this country.

Gwen Diehn's avatar

I have long suspected that t

Kayilka's avatar

Recently, while surfing the internet, I came across a meme that said, "I don't do well in situations."

That's how I feel most of the time. I'm overwhelmed, overstimulated, and feel like I don't belong anywhere. I don't know the rules, don't understand the scripts, feel like everything I say and do is wrong, and have gotten tired of trying to conform to other people's expectations. Trying to fit in means I'm constantly on edge, worried I'm failing at being a person. I can only imagine how exhausting it must have been for Princess Diana to find herself in a role that required her to be "on" all the time.

As it turns out, I do enjoy other people who also have ADHD. I feel like we just get each other, so if someone at a picnic wants to wax poetic about the evolutionary connection between turkeys and dinosaurs, that's fine by me.

Mmerose's avatar

I'm at an age where I have trains of thought about "what if" I'd made different choices, etc. Just this afternoon, I was reaching a conclusion about one big "fork in the road," that the outcome would probably have been the same: mysteriously unfulfilled talent, everybody, most of all me, wondering how I could be so likable and hard-working and honest and even flashes of brilliance, but...... Getting diagnosed late doesn't un-burn the bridges. It also doesn't change the cognitive pattern that always nips at the heels of common taking care of business.